英語が話せるようになるまでの話

10,022 Comments


追記：英語習得について議論していた２篇のブログ記事を元にこの文章を書いたのですが、片方が非表示になっているようなのでこちらからも削除しました。

インターネット界隈では，英語の話は盛り上がりますね．上記の話はどちらもわかるなあと思って，面白く拝読しました．私の意見は，２つ目の返答ブログを書いた方の意見に似ていますが（特に「プログラミングという力で優れているのだから，前向きになれば良い」というメッセージ），せっかくなので他にも自分の所感を書きたいと思います．

私は日本の英語教育は，もちろん改善点はあるんでしょうが，まあそれはそれで１つの形で良いんじゃないかと思っている派です．現状のカリキュラムが目的としてることの１つである，英語が読めるようになることにおいて，それなりのレベルの教育を提供しているからです． 1  自分の場合は，中学で orange をオランゲ，tangerine をタンゲリネと覚えると良いよ，という先生から英語を学んでいました．外国人の先生もいましたが，クラスでは当然日本語が飛び交って，「このクラスは悪夢だ！」と言って授業放棄した外国人教員がいたり，often をオフトンと発音するオーストラリア出身の先生を「お布団」と揶揄したり，あまつさえ猥褻な単語の意味を女性の外国人教員に質問に行くような男子中学生がいたりと，しょうもない学習環境だったと記憶しています．高校に入ると，listening か speaking かのクラスを選択することができましたが，能動的に話す speaking はめんどくさいので消去法で listening を選んだ気がします．

自分の性格もありますが，英語で一番好きだったのは文法と品詞分解で，英文の構造をパズルのように考えるのが好きでした．テストで及第点を取ることはできたのですが，「英語」を学んでいるのとは違っていたんだと思います．これは上のブログの著者の方の言葉を借りれば，ニッチな英語スキルを積み重ねていたのでしょう． 2 高校卒業まで，もちろん英語を話したこともなければ，洋楽や海外ラジオが好きみたいなこともなかったので，英語を意図的に聞いたこともありませんでした．海外旅行や短期留学なども経験がありません．「生きた英語」って何だ，というようなレベルでした．

色んな成り行きで，高校を出てアメリカの大学に入ることになったのが自分に取っての転機でした．当然話されてる英語はわかりませんでしたが，辞書を使いながら大学の教科書を読むことはできました．日本の高校英語でシェークスピアが読めるとは思いませんが，理工系の教科書は読めるものです．数式の多い理工系の大学基礎科目は概念理解が出来れば何とかなりましたし，何より日本の高校の教育水準は悪くないので，そもそもの知識もありました．大学では真面目に勉強をして（最初の１年は新しいことを学んだと言うより，知っていた内容を英語でもう一度学び直す感じだったのですが，それが調整期間になって良かったと今では思います），卒業後は大学院に入って博士号を取得し，アメリカで研究職として就職しました． 3 ざっくりしてますが，こと英語を学ぶことに関しては，特に山場も思い出もないところが実際のところです．特筆すべきことはあまりありません．

よく似た話では，英語を使えるようになるまでの「苦労話」を聞かれることがあるのですが，私には話せるような苦労話がありません．常に不便は感じていたのかもしれません。だけどそれを苦労と捉えたこともなければ，それまでの自分の経験に原因があると思ったこともありませんでした．話の成り行き上，苦労したことにした方が角が立たない場合は「subway club というサンドイッチを頼んだら crab （蟹）サンドイッチが出てきたよ」とか「焼き肉で meat lover というセットを頼んだら meat と rubber が出てきた．ゴム肉でした」などの話を適当にでっちあげることにしています．全て作り話です．あえて言うなら「苦労したことないですか」と聞かれて「ないです」と答えると，虚勢を張っていると思われたり，優秀な人は良いですね，みたいな表層的な反応をされることが一番の苦労です（みたいな禅問答ができるでしょうか．） 4 アメリカで外国人が直面するだろう諸々の洗礼を受けながら，４年経ち，８年経ち，気付けばそれなりに英語が使えるようになっていたのだと思います．１つ目のブログの著者の方が悩んでること（言ってることがわからない，飲み会は意味わからない，云々）は一通り体験していますし，いずれ話のネタになります．大上段から講釈を垂れる立場にはいませんが，真面目に自分と向き合い生きることで，時間が解決するに違いありません．なのでそんなことでは腐らず，著者の方のエンジニアとしての成功を心より祈念しています！

方法論などはないと思うのですが，自分が英語についてやったことを無理矢理挙げるのなら 5，１つ能動的にやったと言えることは，わからないことをわからないままにしないことでした．知らない表現に遭遇したら，その場で「スペル，発音，例文」をざっと見る，くらいのことです．その場で絶対に覚えよう，というガリガリした感じではないのですが，何かの役に立っていたのだと思いたいです． 6 大体，４年くらい経ったら英語が聞ける感じになっ て，８年くらい経ったら英語が話せる感じでした．そして今に至ります．最近は，知的な英単語などをあまり知らないことに問題意識を持ったので，Economist やら NYT などを読んで蘊蓄を言えるようになることを目指し，アメリカに来て初めて単語を覚えようと勉強するようになりました．これは13年目くらいからで，今後もまだまだ続くと思います．

---

自分の経験だけで冗長になってしまったのですが，少しだけ一般的なことを言いたいと思います．一般的と言っても，自分や周りの日本人を見てての感想でしかないのですが：

  • 日本では普通の受験英語しか学んだことがない人が
  • ６年間の日本の中高の英語教育の後に
  • 英語圏の大学に入って
  • 辞書を使いながら，英語で書かれた大学レベルの教科書が読め
  • 勉強についていけて，大学からは落第しない
  • だから４年くらいで大学を卒業できる
  • 卒業する頃にはそれなりにコミュニケーションもできて
  • 人によっては大学院に入学，卒業して
  • 現地なり，日本なりで仕事を見つけて働いている

自分が仲の良かった友人は，真面目で勤勉な人が多かったと思いますが，上記に該当する人が多かったように思います．私も含めて，何らかの特殊スキルや，子どもの頃の海外経験があったわけでもない日本人です．多くの日本人が，日本の高校までの英語教育を足がかりに，アメリカの大学で学ぶ素地がきちんとできていて，落第せずに滞在資格を失わず，学生をやっている間に勤勉で真面目な生活を送れば，５年くらい経ったら英語を使えるようになっている．これは誇張があるわけでもなく，一般的な日本人が十分達成できる水準です． 7 もちろん不便なこともあるし，腹立たしいこともあるし，人間関係が構築しづらいこともあるけど，そういうのは生きていればどこに住んでいても起こることで，英語と因果関係があるのかはわかりませんので，長い目でみて気楽にやるのが良いのではないかと思います．

まとめますと，日本の英語教育は，目的の１つである「読み」については良い線いってるんじゃないか，と思います．何故そう思うかについて，学部留学した友人を見ると，その日本の受験英語が取っ掛かりになって，一定レベルの英語を使うのに支障がない，立派に仕事をしている大人になっている人は少なくない，という理由を挙げました．あと，もう少し一般的な話で，（中学高校の）６年間程度でで何かができるようになるという前提自体が，森羅万象の物事の深みに思いが及んでいない無理な期待であり，ある意味おこがましい話だとも思います．数学・理科を６年勉強したけど何もできない，って怒る人は聞いたことありませんし，スポーツだって楽器だって，プログラミング言語だって同じなのかと思います．英語も同様で，自分のライフワークとして少しずつ積み上げることが大事ではないでしょうか．

ーーー
高校のたった３年間で　できることなんか限られとる　全部やろう思てもムリや
そやから豊玉の練習は　オフェンス８に ディフェンス２くらいのもんや
そらあ 批判もあるけどな　そんでええのや

最後に北野先生の名言を借りました．一度に全てできなくても，少しずつできることが増えていけば，そんでええんじゃないですか．

Notes:

  1. ちなみに「読み書き」ではありません．日本の英語教育が「読み書き偏重」だと思ってる人が，どれくらいの英語を「書ける」のかはよく知りません． ↩
  2. ただニッチと言っても役に立ってると思います．私の今の英語力は全てこれらの土台の上にあるのは明白ですし． ↩
  3. 余談ですが，日本の会社勤めの人はポスドクは就職と認めてくれないようですが，１つのポジションの競争率が50倍を超えることもあるような確固とした「就職」です．以前，給料を貰っているのか聞かれたことがありますが，非常に失礼な質問であることを自覚して欲しいものです．まあこれは完全に余談です．笑 ↩
  4. 理屈っぽいウザいことを言うと，苦労の定義は人によって違うので，人の苦労話を聞いても自分に関係ない可能性があります．例えば「オタクっぽい男性に電子回路の話を２時間ぶっ通しで話された」を苦労や苦行と感じる人がいるのは想像に難くないですが，私は楽しく聞ける可能性があるのです．「苦労」は主観的なものだ，という好例です． ↩
  5. なんて書きながら，小学校の時の塾の友達との一件を思い出しました．友人が「お前はどうやって勉強してるんだ」としつこく聞いてきて「特別なことは何もやってない」というのを絶対に信じてくれない，ということがあったのです．最終的には，家に招いて一緒に勉強することになった，という何だか色々と懐かしい事件でした．この友人は嫌いではなかったんですが，当時からコツコツとした積み重ねをする前に方法論にこだわる姿勢（何か上手いやり方があるんじゃないか，みたいな）に対して，違和感がありました． ↩
  6. ちなみに，私は同様のことを日本語の知らない表現に対しても行うので，これは一般的な自分の習慣なのだろうと思います．少し前に学んだお気に入りの日本語は「諧謔を弄する」です．意味わかりますか？ ↩
  7. もちろん，お金について，親の理解についてなど，色んな他の要素ももちろんあるでしょう．また，生活がだらけてしまい，学習どころではない日本人留学生も存在します．それはどこに住んでいても同じです． ↩

10,022 thoughts on “英語が話せるようになるまでの話”

  7. The Seattle Kraken signed general manager Ron Francis to a three-year contract extension Wednesday, two weeks removed from a stirring run to the second round of the playoffs in just their second season. Francis, 60, now is signed through the 2026-27 season. Financial terms were not released by the club. "Ron has done remarkable work over the last four years and deserves this recognition," Seattle co-owner Samantha Holloway said.
    [url=https://vtor.net ]kraken даркнет [/url]
    "He has built a tremendous team, putting Seattle hockey on the map. He is building for long-term success and is dedicated to our city, our fans and our community." The Kraken lost in Game 7 to the Dallas Stars on May 15 after completing a 46-28-8 mark in the regular season. The Kraken knocked off defending champion Colorado in the first round. The Kraken went 27-49-6 in their expansion season. --Field Level Media

  8. The Seattle Kraken know the situation they're in. They trail the Dallas Stars three games to two in their best-of-seven Western Conference semifinal series, with Game 6 Saturday in Seattle. "It's do-or-die next game," Kraken forward Jordan Eberle said.
    [url=https://vtor.net ]krmp.cc [/url]
    "This is when it gets exciting. These are the games we want to play in." The Kraken trailed 2-1 in their opening-round series against the defending Stanley Cup champion Colorado Avalanche before rallying to win in seven games. So they've come back in a series before already this spring. "I'm confident we can come back in this series. It's far from over," said Kraken defenseman Adam Larsson, who had a goal in Thursday's 5-2 loss at Dallas.

    "One thing with this team, we have never quit. We probably never will." But they'll have to stop the Stars' top line of Roope Hintz, Joe Pavelski and Jason Robertson, which combined for eight points Thursday. Hintz led the way with two goals and an assist, moving him into a tie with Edmonton's Leon Draisaitl for the NHL's scoring lead this postseason with 18 points (eight goals, 10 assists). "He's been just an absolute monster for us this playoff, at the most important times," Stars coach Peter DeBoer said.

    "I mean, (Thursday was) obviously a critical game for our group, and he comes out in the first 10 minutes and basically lets everyone in the building know that he's here to play and dragging our group around, and he's done that the entire playoff. "It's almost been a little bit of a coming-out party for him.
    I think he's been a playoff player before, and a good playoff player, but he hasn't been a dominant playoff player. That's what he looks like in this year's playoffs." Not to be outdone, Pavelski has seven goals in the series and Robertson has three goals and three assists, with all three helpers coming Thursday. Pavelski scored 35 seconds into the second period of Game 5, giving the Stars a 3-0 lead before the Kraken clawed back later in the period to make it 3-2. Hintz scored at 11:20 of the third to give Dallas some breathing room. "I mean, you want to play aggressive, you want to play on your toes, you want to skate.

    That's the way we want to play," Eberle said. "We want to be a quick team, but we have to be smart about it, too. We can't be diving in everywhere and giving them odd-man rushes and opportunities to score. It's just having the smarts and the veteran presence to know when to do that and when not to do it. "I think even if you're 98 percent sure and two percent off, the two percent are the ones that end up in the back of your net. We have to find a way to just continue to play that way but limit the chances they get." The Stars clinched their opening-round victory at Minnesota.

    They hope to advance again on the road Saturday and avoid a Game 7. "Now it's on us to go there and end this on the road, which we did in the (first-round) Minnesota series," DeBoer said. "Hopefully we have the same result." --Field Level Media

  10. The Seattle Kraken, making their first playoff appearance, are one victory away from eliminating the defending Stanley Cup champions. The Kraken can accomplish that feat Friday night at home, where they'll play the Colorado Avalanche in Game 6 of their first-round Western Conference playoff series. Seattle took a 3-2 lead in the best-of-seven series with a 3-2 victory Wednesday in Denver. "We know that the fourth (victory) is going to be the toughest, and they're going to bring everything they have," Kraken defenseman Justin Schultz said.
    [url=https://v2t0r.com ]kraken магазин[/url]
    "I think we've done a pretty good job all year of just focusing on the task at hand, not listening to any outside noise." The Avalanche, who won the Central Division title with a 51-24-7 record (109 points), admitted they're feeling some pressure. "I've said it a million times," Colorado coach Jared Bednar said, "we're putting the most pressure on ourselves out of anybody, right? `Cause we want to win and we want to get rewarded for the hard work we put in for the season, They're a second-year team. They got in the playoffs. They got a good team. They're playing loose. They're confident. Obviously, the guys in the room, in their room, are like, `Well, yeah, we want to win,' but expectations are on our team. "But that's nothing new to our group, either.

    We've dealt with that over the last three or four years, last year especially, and they got the job done. I believe in our team to be able to deal with the expectations." The Avalanche will get Cale Makar, last year's Conn Smythe Award winner as the playoff MVP, back Friday after he received a suspension because of a late hit along the boards on Seattle's Jared McCann in Game 4. But they might be without fellow defenseman Josh Manson, who left Wednesday's game in the second period after reaggravating a lower-body injury. Left winger McCann, who led the Kraken with 40 goals in the regular season, didn't make the trip to Denver for Wednesday's game and doesn't appear likely to return Friday. "He just sent a quick text (Wednesday) night congratulating us," Schultz said. "Obviously, we miss him, and it's probably tough for him to be watching but, hopefully, he heals quickly and we get him back quick.

    We miss `Canner' a lot, but guys are doing a really good job of stepping up right now." Tye Kartye, the American Hockey League's rookie of the year, scored in his NHL debut for the Kraken and goaltender Philipp Grubauer made 26 saves against his former team. "Jared's a big part of our team," Kraken coach Dave Hakstol said. "We did what we've done in the past.
    Somebody (Kartye) stepped in and filled a hole, filled a big hole." Colorado's Nathan MacKinnon scored his third goal of the series Wednesday, but it wasn't enough. The Kraken have scored the opening goal in each of the five games. "It's tough, yeah.

    We didn't have our A-game or our B-game (Wednesday), I don't know why," MacKinnon said. "We just got to find a way to bring Game 7 back here. I think we're just shooting ourselves in the foot. I know it's cliche to say, but I think there's plays to be made out there and we're just not making them for whatever reason right now.
    It's not a matter of work or competitiveness or anything like that." --Field Level Media

  11. The defending champions are on the ropes, and the best team in the NHL has another chance to move on to the second round of the playoffs. All four resuming Friday night feature a Game 6 with potential elimination. The most surprising team on the brink is Colorado, with the series going back to Seattle. There are a pair of second chances in the East, with top-seeded Boston trying to put away Florida and Carolina looking to advance past the New York Islanders.
    [url=https://v2t0r.com ]kraken сайт[/url]
    Out West,     of knocking off Minnesota and moving on. All eyes now are on the Avalanche, who are one loss away from being the first reigning Stanley Cup champion to lose to a team making its first playoff appearance in franchise history. "With the culture we have here, belief is the biggest thing and that?s instilled from the top down, so that?s never going to go away," veteran forward Andrew Cogliano said Thursday.

    "But I think we?re at a point now where action is much louder than words." It's time for action from the Bruins, too, after they missed their first chance to move past the Panthers, with punctuated by uncharacteristic mistakes.
    As captain Patrice Bergeron said afterward, he and his teammates can't give an opportunistic opponent "freebies" as they did in Game 5 at home. Seattle Kraken defenseman Carson Soucy, left, celebrates with center Yanni Gourde, who scored against the Colorado Avalanche during the third period of Game 5 of an NHL hockey first-round playoff series Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Denver.

    (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) Game 6 is on the road at Florida, and the Bruins still have the series lead looking to be the 10th Presidents' Trophy winners in the past 11 years to win at least one series. "I?m sure we?re going to come back with a real good, determined effort," Boston coach Jim Montgomery said.

    "I have a lot of confidence in our team." Confidence isn't lacking for the Avalanche, either, especially after their Cup run a year ago. They'll also get a boost with the return of 2022 playoff MVP Cale Makar from a one-game suspension. But much like Boston, the pressure is on Colorado. "They?re playing loose, they?re confident," coach Jared Bednar said of the Kraken. "Obviously the guys in their room are like, `Yeah, we want to win,? but expectations are on our team." HURRICANES at ISLANDERS, Carolina leads 3-2 (7 p.m.

    EDT, TBS) The Hurricanes lost despite outshooting the Islanders 36-22 and dictating for long stretches. Two Islanders goals came off Carolina turnovers, and the for another. Otherwise, it might've been the team's best 5-on-5 game of the series. "You feel like you played good enough to win, but the bounces didn?t quite go our way," Hurricanes forward Seth Jarvis said.

    "But for us, even watching video you could tell, we played the way we want to play." after being knocked out of Game 4 on a hard hit into the boards, according to coach Rod Brind'Amour, who didn't rule out the possibility of going with Frederik Andersen in net after Antti Raanta started the first five games. There are no questions about Ilya Sorokin being back in net for the Islanders after he made 34 saves to help New York win its first elimination game.

    Now comes another, this one with home-ice advantage and the chance to push the series to a Game 7 in Raleigh. BRUINS at PANTHERS, Boston leads 3-2 (7:30 p.m., TNT) The word that Florida coach Paul Maurice keeps using is freedom. Yes, there?s an obvious pressure when facing elimination - which the Panthers were in Game 5 in Boston before winning 4-3 - but there's also much less from the outside going against the team that had the best regular season in NHL history. "These are hard games for these guys to play," Maurice said.

    "You just have to mentally process one, and fight, and that brings that freedom. That?s the exact word I used before that game. You want to play with a freedom." Sergei Bobrovsky looked like his best self, and a stop on a breakaway in the final second of regulation got Florida to overtime - on a night the Bruins outshot the NHL?s most-prolific shooting team in the regular season 47-25. "The veteran players and also your highest-paid players, these are the games where the pressure has to be on their shoulders, and they have to rise to the occasion," Maurice said.

    "And he did. Everything that we could have hoped for from Sergei, he delivered." The Panthers have not won two elimination games in the same series, or the same playoffs, since 1996. They may or may not have Ryan Lomberg for their latest attempt, with Maurice calling the forward a game-time decision. STARS at WILD, Dallas leads 3-2 (9:30 p.m., TBS) Joe Pavelski could return for the Stars in their first chance to advance after missing the past four games in concussion protocol from a hit from Minnesota's Matt Dumba in the series opener. Coach Peter DeBoer said Pavelski, at 38 the second-oldest player in the playoffs and a key leader for Dallas, was traveling to the Twin Cities after just about a full practice. The Stars have survived so far without Pavelski, thanks to the production of center with 11 points, and goaltender Jake Oettinger, who stopped all 27 shots he faced Tuesday in Game 5 for the first shutout of this postseason. Another win would vault the Stars into the second round and a matchup against either Colorado or Seattle. "We have a great opportunity ahead of us," said Oettinger, who has a .925 save percentage so far.

    "This is exactly where we want to be." AVALANCHE AT KRAKEN, Seattle leads 3-2 (10 p.m., TNT) The Kraken are trying to treat the moment just as if it's any other situation. But players and coach Dave Hakstol know the gravity of the situation. "We know what?s on the line, believe me," Hakstol said.
    "We want to go home and play well and get the job done at home." The Kraken have put Nathan MacKinnon and the high-flying Avalanche on their heels by scoring first in all five games. The Avalanche would like to reverse that trend and send the series back to Denver for a Game 7 Sunday. "We?ve got to have some desperation ... and just find a way," forward Mikko Rantanen said. ___ AP Sports Writers Pat Graham, Tim Reynolds, Aaron Beard, Jimmy Golen, Stephen Hawkins and Dave Campbell contributed. ___ AP NHL playoffs:     Colorado Avalanche goaltender Alexandar Georgiev reacts after giving up a goal to Seattle Kraken center Morgan Geekie during the second period of Game 5 of an NHL hockey first-round playoff series Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) Boston Bruins head coach Jim Montgomery watches from the bench during the third period of Game 5 in the first round of the NHL hockey playoffs, Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Boston. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa) Florida Panthers left wing Matthew Tkachuk (19) leaps on goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky (72) while celebrating after scoring the game-winning goal against the Boston Bruins during overtime of Game 5 in the first round of the NHL hockey playoffs, Wednesday, April 26, 2023, in Boston. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa) Carolina Hurricanes' Stefan Noesen skates on the ice following the Hurricanes' loss to the New York Islanders in Game 5 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series in Raleigh, N.C., Tuesday, April 25, 2023. (AP Photo/Karl B DeBlaker) Carolina Hurricanes goaltender Antti Raanta (32) jumps up to block a shot of the New York Islanders with Jean-Gabriel Pageau (44) close by during the third period of Game 5 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series in Raleigh, N.C., Tuesday, April 25, 2023. (AP Photo/Karl B DeBlaker) Dallas Stars goaltender Jake Oettinger, center, and teammates Radek Faksa (12) and Luke Glendening (11) celebrate the team's 4-0 win against the Minnesota Wild in Game 5 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series, Tuesday, April 25, 2023, in Dallas. (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez) Dallas Stars goaltender Jake Oettinger reaches up to glove a shot from the Minnesota Wild during the third period of Game 5 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series Tuesday, April 25, 2023, in Dallas. (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez) Minnesota Wild left wing Marcus Johansson, bottom, and Dallas Stars' Max Domi (18) fall to the ice after colliding as they chased the puck during the third period of Game 5 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup first-round playoff series Tuesday, April 25, 2023, in Dallas. (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez)

  17. Barcelona stress an present was sent to Lionel Messi in the interest him to reappear to Bivouac Nou – without thought the Argentine claiming that the staff could not settle their proposal.

    Messi was revealed of engage this summer after his compress with Paris Saint-Germain expired and has been in talks down a gain to Barcelona.
    [url=http://economist.georgiatoday.ge/pages/online_casino_canada_legal__best_online_casino_in_canada__safest_online_casino_canada__caesars_online_casino_canada.html ]best online casino [/url]
    However, without thought La Liga approving Barcelona’s financial script to capital a shake up quest of their latest talisman, Messi opted to procure the prod to Biggest Band Soccer side Inter Miami, effectively career occasion on his playing dash in Europe.

    In a shared assessment with Spanish newspapers Sport and Mundo Deportivo on Wednesday, Messi claimed that he wanted to put out an early settling settled his next make a deep impression on and said he was uncomfortable with the notion of Barcelona needing to sell players in order to wherewithal his return.

    Messi also indicated that Barcelona’s tender was not concrete.

    ‘Multifarious things were missing,’ he said.

    ‘The association, today, was not in a stand to accredit 100 per cent that I could return. And it is understandable, due to the place that the blackjack is successful via, and that is how I truism it.’

  18. Barcelona insist an offer was sent to Lionel Messi for the sake of him to reappear to Camp Nou – without thought the Argentine claiming that the club could not affirm their proposal.

    Messi was out of commitment this summer after his condense with Paris Saint-Germain expired and has been in talks all about a reimbursement to Barcelona.
    [url=https://colegioipe.com.br/pag/?best_online_casino_singapore_reviews__online_casino_real_money_no_deposit_singapore__online_casinos_singapore__free_online_slots_singapore_real_money.html ] online casino [/url]
    Still, without thought La Liga approving Barcelona’s fiscal plan to back a shake up in place of their one-time talisman, Messi opted to concoct the go to Biggest Band Soccer side Inter Miami, effectively calling time on his playing profession in Europe.

    In a roast talk with with Spanish newspapers Sport and Mundo Deportivo on Wednesday, Messi claimed that he wanted to make an at cock crow purposefulness upwards his next get going and said he was uncomfortable with the notion of Barcelona needing to handle players in scale to nest egg his return.

    Messi also indicated that Barcelona’s furnish was not concrete.

    ‘Many things were missing,’ he said.

    ‘The nightclub, today, was not in a position to confirm 100 per cent that I could return. And it is understandable, just to the situation that the blackjack is contemporary owing to, and that is how I saw it.’

  19. Barcelona insist an present was sent to Lionel Messi for the sake of him to return to Outr‚ Nou – consideration the Argentine claiming that the company could not confirm their proposal. Barcelona insist an make was sent to Lionel Messi instead of him to reappear to Outr‚ Nou – despite the Argentine claiming that the staff could not affirm their proposal.

    Messi was into public notice of commitment this summer after his promise with Paris Saint-Germain expired and has been in talks all about a gain to Barcelona.
    [url=http://womantowoman.tv/dev/inc/best_online_casino_india_no_deposit_bonus__online_casinos_in_india__ontario_india_casinos__best_online_casinos_in_india.html ]best online casino [/url]
    No matter how, without thought La Liga approving Barcelona’s financial method to capital a shake up quest of their last jibber-jabber, Messi opted to coerce the prod to Biggest Band Soccer side Inter Miami, effectively pursuit time on his playing dash in Europe.

    In a dive talk with with Spanish newspapers Спорт and Mundo Deportivo on Wednesday, Messi claimed that he wanted to put out an anciently determination settled his next get going and said he was uncomfortable with the notion of Barcelona needing to handle players in prepared to lolly his return.

    Messi also indicated that Barcelona’s tender was not concrete.

    ‘Divers things were missing,’ he said.

    ‘The nightclub, today, was not in a slant to bind 100 per cent that I could return. And it is understandable, well-earned to the state of affairs that the club is going owing to, and that is how I maxim it.’

  47. Barcelona insist an offer was sent to Lionel Messi instead of him to consideration to Bivouac Nou – regardless of the Argentine claiming that the company could not settle their proposal.

    Barcelona exhort an offer was sent to Lionel Messi for the sake of him to turn to Camp Nou – despite the Argentine claiming that the company could not affirm their proposal.
    Messi was in view of engage this summer after his promise with Paris Saint-Germain expired and has been in talks over a reoccur to Barcelona.

    Still, ignoring La Liga approving Barcelona’s financial method to fund a touch in place of their one-time jabber, Messi opted to make the prod to Outstanding Band Soccer side Inter Miami, effectively career time on his playing career in Europe.
    [url=https://temperandtantrum.com/wp-content/pgs/real_money_online_casino_australia__real_money_online_casino_australia__best_online_casinos_australia.html ]best online casin [/url]
    In a shared talk with Spanish newspapers Sport and Mundo Deportivo on Wednesday, Messi claimed that he wanted to make an initial purposefulness upwards his next get going and said he was uncomfortable with the idea of Barcelona needing to offer players in prepared to lolly his return.

    Messi also indicated that Barcelona’s offer was not concrete.

    ‘Sundry things were missing,’ he said.

    ‘The association, today, was not in a slant to accredit 100 per cent that I could return. And it is understandable, apposite to the setting that the union is going via, and that is how I saw it.’

  48. Barcelona asseverate an present was sent to Lionel Messi instead of him to reappear to Camping-site Nou – without thought the Argentine claiming that the club could not sanction their proposal.
    [url=https://detailsoftravel.com/wp-includes/pages/best_online_casinos_in_singapore__online_gambling_singapore__online_casino_singapore.html ]best online casin [/url]
    Messi was out of contract this summer after his contract with Paris Saint-Germain expired and has been in talks down a return to Barcelona.

    Still, without thought La Liga approving Barcelona’s fiscal script to fund a shake up in place of their former merry thought speak in, Messi opted to coerce the remind to Biggest League Soccer side Inter Miami, effectively calling age on his playing tear in Europe.

    In a joint talk with Spanish newspapers Sport and Mundo Deportivo on Wednesday, Messi claimed that he wanted to perceive b complete an anciently settling over his next make a deep impression on and said he was uncomfortable with the concept of Barcelona needing to barter players in prepared to fund his return.

    Messi also indicated that Barcelona’s put up for sale was not concrete.

    ‘Divers things were missing,’ he said.

    ‘The nightclub, today, was not in a stand to accredit 100 per cent that I could return. And it is understandable, due to the state of affairs that the association is going via, and that is how I saw it.’

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.